The construction contractor performance evaluation as a control mechanism.
Iselin, Steven Richard.
Smith, Raymond W.
MetadataShow full item record
This study examined the Naval Facilities Engineering Command's current use of construction contractor performance evaluations (SF 1420) from the viewpoint of accepted control and measurement theory. Surveys of field contract administrators, supervisory civil engineers, field contract specialists, and construction contractors were completed to assess their use of and views about the evaluations. The study concluded that: (1) NAVFAC lacks standards of performance to describe the distinction between satisfactory, outstanding, and unsatisfactory performances (2) Contractors are not generally aware of the evaluation process; (3) Evaluations are not used to provide contractors feedback; (4) Evaluators are not well trained; (5) Evaluations are not fully utilized; (6) The data base of evaluation information is inadequate. The study recommends that: (1) NAVFAC issue a policy statement to contractors to clarify the evaluations uses, standards, and performance elements; (2) interim evaluations be issued to provide contractors feedback; (3) contractors receive copies of all their evaluations; (4) evaluators receive uniform training on completion of evaluations; (5) SF 1420 be modified to allow for a more specific evaluation.
Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Ricks, Shemeka S.; Robertson, Tony I.; Jolliffe, Dennis D. (Monterey, California: Naval Postgraduate School, 2013-12);Award-fee arrangements are a valuable contractual approach for the Department of Defense (DoD) when used properly. Award-fee contracts provide incentives to motivate contractor performance in areas critical to program ...
An investigation of innovative construction contracting methods used by the general services administration Baldwin, Joel L. (2001-06);In the last decade, award fee contracts have gained popularity on operations service contracts within the federal government contracting arena. Recently, award fees have been added to fixed-price construction contracts. ...
Wolfgeher, Stephane L. (Monterey, California: Naval Postgraduate School, 2009-12);The Air Force Officer Evaluation System's purpose is to provide feedback, document a record of performance and potential, and provide centralized selection boards sound information for decision making. Officer Performance ...