The V-22: a turning point in Congressional behavior?
Szczublewski, Kenneth J.
Stockton, Paul N.
Garrett, Stephen Lurie
MetadataShow full item record
Why do legislators vote for some defense programs but against others? This issue is especially important now that Congress faces the need to cut defense programs while preserving U.S. security. The history of the V-22 offers a prime case study for examining congressional voting behavior for the post-Cold War era. This thesis reviews the literature on three possible explanations for congressional voting behavior: parochialism (the desire to benefit constituents), the Military-Industrial Complex or MIC (where votes are "bought" by industry campaigns contributions), and the personal preferences of individual members. The thesis uses logit equation to test and assess the validity of these hypothesis in the case of the V-22. No reliable connection was found between personal preference and voting on the V-22. Liberal Democrats that were assumed to be "dovish" on defense spending were just as likely as "hawkish" conservative Republicans to support this program. Nor was any evidence found to support the MIC hypothesis that voting is driven by PAC dollars. The likelihood of a representative supporting the V-22 actually decreased as PAC contributions increased. The parochial hypothesis was supported in the House but not in the Senate. Further research is required to find alternative explanations for defense voting behavior in the post-Cold War era.
Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Adams, David Allan (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 1997-12);Pursuing a ship-based missile defense capability could thrust the naval service into one of the most heated controversies of the past three decades: the congressional debate over the desirability--or danger--of erecting ...
Brook, Douglas A. (2005);In antidumping and countervailing duty cases, why do commissioners of the International Trade Commission vote as they do? Commissioners are presented with the same petitions, listen to the same oral arguments, have ...
Brazil for sale? does Sino-Brazilian trade or investment significantly influence Brazil's United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) voting pattern? Bailey, Kathleen S. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2011-12);This thesis examines whether Sino-Brazilian trade or investment significantly influences Brazil's voting in the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA). To examine this relationship, this thesis regresses a dataset of UNGA ...