Fitting firepower score models to the battle of Kursk data
Lucas, Thomas W.
MetadataShow full item record
This thesis applies several Firepower Score attrition algorithms to real data. These algorithms are used in highly aggregated combat models to predict attrition and movement rates. The quality of the available historical data for validation of attrition models is poor. Most accessible battle data contain only starting sizes and casualties, sometimes only for one side. A detailed database of the Battle of Kursk of World War II, the largest tank battle in history, has recently been developed by Dupuy Institute (TDI). The data is two-sided, time phased (daily), highly detailed, and covers 15 days of the campaign. According to combat engagement intensity, three different data sets are extracted from the Battle of Kursk data. RAND's Situational Force Scoring, Dupuy's QJM and the ATLAS ground attrition algorithms are applied to these data sets. Fitted versus actual personnel and weapon losses are analyzed for the different approaches and data sets. None of the models fits better in all cases. In all of the models and for both sides, the Fighting Combat Unit Data set gives the best fit. All the models tend to overestimates battle casualties, particularly for the Germans
Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Turkes, Turker (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2000-03);This thesis extends previous research on validating Lanchester's equations with real data. The quality of the available, historical data for validation of attrition models is poor. Most accessible battle data contain only ...
Numerical Determination of the Parity-Condition Parameter for Lanchester-Type Equations of Modern Warfare Brown, Gerald G.; Taylor, James G. (1978);This paper presents a simple numerical procedure for determining the parity-condition parameter for deterministic Lanchester-type combat between two homogeneous forces. Deterministic dierentidequation combat models are ...
Dinges, John A. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2001-06);This thesis explores the validation of Lanchester equations as models of the attrition process for the Battle of Kursk in World War II. The methodology and results of this study extend previous validation efforts undertaken ...