Evaluating the analytic hierarchy process and recommended modifications for its use in multi-attribute decision making
McQuail, William H.
Marshall, Kneale T.
Kemple, William G.
MetadataShow full item record
The Combined Arms Analysis Directorate of the Training and Doctrine Analysis Command (TRAC) uses the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) to evaluate the contribution of modernization initiatives to U.S. Army capabilities. This thesis identifies several problems with using AHP. Most significantly, AHP can cause rank reversal of alternatives if a new alternative is considered, even if the new alternative has the same attribute levels as one of the previous alternatives. This thesis proposes several modifications that would improve results when AHP is used. It contains a different method of weight fitting that appears to provide alternative weights that are more accurate than the traditional AHP eigenvalue method. This thesis has two proposals for improving the nine point integer scale by which pairwise comparisons are made. Most significantly, this thesis proposes a modification to AHP that will maintain a ratio scale and avoid rank reversals. This last improvement requires the decision maker to establish and maintain units of measurement. Additionally, the decision maker must make comparisons of attributes to establish a meaningful scale not sensitive to the abundance or lack of alternatives considered. If units are maintained and the decision maker is consistent in the pairwise comparisons, there will be no rank reversals
Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Gaspar, Tamas S. (Monterey, California: Naval Postgraduate School, 1999-06);Current defense planning methods do not ensure a direct connection between national security objectives and military tasks. The Strategy-to-Task method provides a framework for solving this deficiency by establishing a ...
Ruegger, Keith L. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2008-09);Maritime domain awareness (MDA) entails knowing what is happening in the oceans and waterways that could affect the security or environment of the United States. With a focus on potential attack vessels (PAV) as threats ...
Hills, Allison (Monterey, CaliforniaNaval Postgraduate School, 2012-06);This thesis develops a model that provides a credible and reliable rough order magnitude (ROM) Life Cycle Cost Estimate (LCCE) for a newly constructed U. S. Navy Dock Landing Ship, LSD(X), over the various phases of design, ...