Issues in strategic thought: from Clausewitz to al-Qaida
Nomura, Ryan C.
MetadataShow full item record
Ever since the quickening of social and technological change that began during the Napoleonic era, there have been many strategic debates inspired by those developments. Six are discussed in this thesis Jomini vs. Clausewitz How useful are principles of war Mahan vs. Mackinder Is either land or sea power inherently more valuable for achieving national aims Bernhardi vs. Bloch Did industrialization make war an impractical endeavor Douhet vs. Mitchell What is the role of air power in national defense Brodie vs. Wohlstetter Is nuclear deterrence robust, or is there a delicate balance of terror Giap vs. Galula Can conventional forces defeat insurgencies, and, if so, how Though these debates are listed in their rough chronological order of appearance, they do not reflect discrete blocks of time and often overlap. The purpose of this thesis is not to judge whether any particular debater was right or wrong. Rather, the intent is to consider the debate itself. While problem definition may seem a less-than-ambitious undertaking, it is nonetheless necessary for understanding the root causes and conduct of war over the last two centuries, as well as for the understanding of possible forms of future conflict. In some cases the differences between the debaters are apparent. In others, the differences are subtle. The conclusion summarizes the debates and addresses underlying themes or patterns that were identified during the course of this research. Last, some possible future strategic debates are identified, along with some topics that may require further research.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Bryans, Robert T. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2002-12);Since the end of the Cold War two debates have largely shaped Western views of Islam: Islam's relevance in statecraft and the potential "clash of civilizations" between Islam and the West. Those joined in these debates ...
Adams, Reginald C. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 1990-06);On March 23, 1983, then-President Ronald Reagan challenged a group of engineers and scientists to make nuclear weapons impotent and obsolete. This challenge led to the beginning of a new era in space technology and strategic ...
Keenan, Joseph M. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 1998-06);Some of the most heated debates taking place on Capitol Hill surround a proposed American national missile defense system. The debate is not new. For twenty years, the Anti-Ballistic Missile (ABM) Treaty and its underlying ...