Optimal commitment of forces in some Lanchester-type combat models
Taylor, James G.
MetadataShow full item record
This paper shows that one can determine whether or not it is beneficial for the victor to initially commit as many forces as possible to battle in Lanchester-type combat between two homogeneous forces by considering the instantaneous casualty-exchange ratio. It considers the initial-commitment decison as a one-sided static optimization problem and examines this nonlinear program for each of three decision criteria (victor's losses, loss ratio, and loss difference) and for each of two different battle-termination conditions (given force-level breakpoint and given force-ratio breakpoint) . The paper's main contribution is to show how to determine the sign of the partial derivative of the decision criterion with respect to the victor's initial force level for general combat dynamics without explicitly solving the Lanchester-type combat equations. Consequently, the victor's optimal initialcommitment decision many times may be determined from how the instantaneous casualty-exchange ratio varies with changes in the victor's force level and time. Convexity of the instantaneous casualty-exchange ratio is shown to imply convexity of the decision criterion so that conditions of decreasing marginal returns may be identified also without solving the combat equations. The optimal initial-commitment decision is shown to be sensitive to the decision criterion for fixed force-ratio breakpoint battles.
NPS Report NumberNPS 55-77-2
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Mortlock, Robert (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2017-07); NPS-AM-17-211This Enhanced Combat Helmet (ECH) case study encourages critical analysis of a U.S. Defense Department project at two key decision points: project start and production. The case centers on the development, testing, and ...
Muldoon, Richard C.; KheeLoon “Richard” Foo; Hoi Kok “Daniel” Siew; Cheow Siang Ng; Victor Yeo; Teng Chye ”Lawrence” Lim; Chun Hock Sng; Keith Jude Ho; David Bauer; Steven B. Carroll; Glen B. Quast; Lance Lantier; Bruce Schuette; Paul R. Darling; The System Engineering & Integration Curriculum Students (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2001-12);Distributing naval combat power into many small ships and unmanned air vehicles that capitalize on emerging technology offers a transformational way to think about naval combat in the littorals in the 2020 time frame. ...
McGunnigle, John. (Monterey, California: Naval Postgraduate School, 1999-12);This thesis addresses the military value of information in conflict. It is composed of three complimentary experiments. The first experiment uses a simple contest to assess how military decision makers perceive and use ...