A study of wind stress determination methods from a ship and an offshore tower
Frederickson, Paul A.
Davidson, Kenneth L.
Edson, James B.
MetadataShow full item record
Comparisons are made between surface wind stress measurements obtained by the inertial-dissipation and direct covariance methods on a stable offshore tower and by the inertial-dissipation and bulk methods on a ship. The shipboard inertial-dissipation friction velocity measurements agreed very well with both the tower inertialdissipation and direct covariance values, to within 62% in the mean and with a 10% or lower rms scatter. The inertial-dissipation determinations also exhibited less scatter than the tower direct covariance measurements. A detailed error analysis indicates that shipboard inertial-dissipation wind stress values can have an accuracy of better than 15% in near-neutral conditions, as compared to an accuracy of roughly 30% for the bulk method. The accuracy of shipboard inertial-dissipation values was shown to be equal to that of direct covariance measurements from a tower. Errors in inertial-dissipation wind stress values are most likely due primarily to deviations from the assumed balance between turbulent kinetic energy production and dissipation and to errors in determining the wind speed variance spectra. Errors in direct covariance measurements are most likely due primarily to finite time averaging and to flow distortion effects, unless great care is taken to minimize or correct for flow distortion. The high accuracy of inertial-dissipation wind stress values found in this study, combined with the well-known difficulties in shipboard direct covariance measurements due to platform motion and flow distortion, demonstrate that the inertial-dissipation method is the best option at present for determining the wind stress from a ship.
RightsThis publication is a work of the U.S. Government as defined in Title 17, United States Code, Section 101. Copyright protection is not available for this work in the United States.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Chambless, Ronald (1978-03);An analysis based primarily on computations is conducted to determine errors in a oombing system similar to that currently under test and development by the Marine Corps. There are many parameters in the system determining ...
Investigations of scalar transfer coefficients in fog during the Coupled Boundary Layers and Air Sea Transfer Experiment : a case study Crofoot, Robert F. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2004-09);The uncertainty in the determination of the momentum and scalar fluxes remains one of the main obstacles to accurate numerical forecasts in low to moderate wind conditions. For example, latent heat fluxes computed from ...
Smith, Stuart D.; Anderson, Robert J.; Oost, Wiebe A.; Kraan, C.; Maat, Nico; DeCosmo, Janice; Katsaros, Kristina B.; Davidson, Kenneth L.; Bumke, Karl; Hasse, Lutz; Chadwick, Helen M. (Kluwer Academic Publishing, 1991-12);Turbulent fluxes have been measured in the atmospheric surface layer from a boom extending upwind from the Dutch offshore research platform Meetpost Noordwijk (MPN) during HEXMAX (Humidity Exchange over the Sea Main ...