Law on the rocks: international law and China’s maritime disputes
Nakata, Jason S.
Clunan, Anne L.
MetadataShow full item record
Maritime disputes in the Western Pacific have increased tensions among East Asian states. This thesis uses three case studies to investigate two questions: first, whether China’s maritime claims and behavior align with international legal principles governing maritime disputes, and second, which IR framework best describes China’s behavior related to its maritime disputes. The first case study examined ten legal rulings on maritime sovereignty and concludes that courts view effective control as a determinative factor in settling maritime disputes. The second case study examined effective control in three of China’s maritime disputes. The analysis revealed Japan’s claim to the Senkaku Islands and China’s claim to the Paracel Islands are strong due to continued demonstrations of effective control. However, the Philippine claim to the Scarborough Shoal using effective control is valid but weak. The final case study showed how China attempts to effective control on its maritime claims using legal warfare. Based on the analysis of Chinese legal warfare, evidence shows two IR frameworks best describe China’s behavior related to its maritime claims. Legal warfare provides a façade for offensive realist behavior; whereas the English School of realism expects China to use legal warfare to conform to some norms while revising other norms.
Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Ali, Muhammad (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2012-12);Since independence, relations between Pakistan and India have been fraught with contentious issues. Most of these conflicts were related to the demarcation of borders and the non-resolution of the Kashmir dispute. The ...
Sailing the calm and rough seas: the influence of wealth and sovereignty in Southeast Asian maritime disputes Ciptadi, Andromeda Windra (Monterey, California: Naval Postgraduate School, 2016-03);Under what conditions do the Association of Southeast Asian Nations members use peaceful means to resolve their maritime disputes? Why do they resort to military action in some cases, and compromise peacefully in others? ...
Preventing escalation in the South China Sea disputed waters: a comparative study of Republic of the Philippines and socialist Republic of Vietnam Askari (Monterey, California: Naval Postgraduate School, 2015-03);The South China Sea is one of the maritime hot spots in the world and perhaps accounts for more clashes than other disputed waters, due to the abundancy of the natural resources that can fulfill the region’s rising demand ...