Aligned incentives could the Army's award system inadvertently be hindering counterinsurgency operations?

Download
Author
Clemmer, Brent Alan.
Date
2009-06Advisor
Simons, Anna
Jansen, Erik
Metadata
Show full item recordAbstract
The United States Army has struggled to institutionalize counterinsurgency operations in the Global War on Terror. The Army's reward system, which drives individual motivation and reflects corporate values, plays a much overlooked role in this struggle. Within the Army, indeed within most organizations, pay, promotion, and awards form the tripod of extrinsic motivation, and represent tools the organization can use to reward specific behavior. Today and for the foreseeable future, both pay and promotion will have limited effects promoting counterinsurgency behavior. The Army's award system, which proudly traces its history to George Washington, was not developed as a complete system until World War I and, in many respects, ceased development after World War II. The current 'Pyramid of Honor,' which focuses on valorous acts, is deeply engrained in Army culture. At the same time significant work and thought have gone into revising the Army's 'capstone' manuals, FM-1 and FM-3.0. These documents, along with a separate manual on counterinsurgency, all revised or created since 9/11, attempt to move the Army in a new direction.This thesis explains the paradox that results. The Army has reached a point where it is telling its soldiers to do one type of action: work by, with, and through the host nation. Yet, it disproportionally delivers awards to those who conduct a separate type of action: engaging and killing the enemy.
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Peacekeepers attend the never again school
Mariano, Stephen J. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 1995-12);This thesis examines the lessons the U.S Army drew from the war in Vietnam and how these lessons influence current Army attitudes toward peace operations. The thesis finds that the Army's failure in Vietnam contributes not ... -
Army space and transformation
Scherer, Clay S. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2005-09);The Army is undergoing a Transformation process, the outcome of which will be an enhanced warfighting capability via the Objective Force. Space is a key enabler for the Army's Objective Force capabilities and Joint combat ... -
Recruiting the cyber leader: an evaluation of the human resource model used for recruiting the Army’s "Cyber Operations Officer"
Nicholson, Wallace C.; Gibbs, Sean A. (Monterey, California: Naval Postgraduate School, 2017-09);For the first time since the creation of the Special Forces branch in 1987, the Army authorized the creation of a new branch, the Cyber branch. With this, the Army joined the ranks of other organizations in this rapidly ...