Mental models, trust, and reliance exploring the effect of human perceptions on automation use
Cassidy, Andrea M.
Shattuck, Lawrence G.
Miller, Nita L.
MetadataShow full item record
Today's military increasingly uses automation to perform or augment the performance of complex tasks. Automated systems that support or even make important decisions require human operators to understand and trust automation in order to rely on it appropriately. This study examined the effect of varying degrees of information about an automated system's reliability on mental model accuracy, trust in, and reliance on automation. Forty-two participants were divided into three groups based on level of information received about the reliability of a simulated automated target detection aid. One group received little information, one group received accurate information, and one group received inaccurate information about the target detection aid's reliability. Each participant completed a series of 120 tasks in which he or she was required to identify the presence of a threat target and then decide whether to use an automated aid for assistance. Results indicate a significant difference between the groups' trust in and reliance on automation. The experimental group that received little information trusted the automation less but relied on it more. These findings, accompanied by observational data collected regarding the formation of mental models, demonstrate the necessity of continued research in the field of automation trust.
Approved for public release, distribution unlimitedHuman Systems Integration Report
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
McGuire, Mollie (2018-04-18);The focus of the current study is to examine reliance on automation using a decision making framework. Specifically, the decision to rely on automation under stressful conditions. Stress consumes executive resources (Hermans ...
Walliser, James C. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2011-06);Automated systems perform functions that were previously executed by a human. When using automation, the role of the human changes from operator to supervisor. For effective operation, the human must appropriately calibrate ...
Clark, Tiffany (Monterey, CA; Naval Postgraduate School, 2018-06);Successful human-machine teaming requires humans to trust machines. While many claim to welcome automation, there is also mistrust of machines, which may stem from more than competence concerns. Human-automation trust ...