Can Major Systematic Reviews Influence Practice Patterns? A Case Study of Episiotomy Trends
Sim, Wee Chung
Caughey, Aaron B.
Howard, David H.
MetadataShow full item record
Purpose Episiotomy is one of the most commonly performed procedures among women of childbearing age in the United States. In 2005, a major systematic review conducted by Hartmann and colleagues recommended against routine use of episiotomy and was widely covered in the media. We assessed the impact of the Hartman et al. study on episiotomy trend. Methods Based on 100 % hospital discharge data from eight states in 2003–2008, we used interrupted time series regression models to estimate the impact of the Hartman et al. review on episiotomy rates. We used mixed-effects regression models to assess whether interhospital variation was reduced over time. Results After controlling for underlying trend, episiotomy rates dropped by 1.4 percentage points after Hartman et al. publication (p\0.01 for spontaneous delivery; p\0.1 for operative delivery). The publication has smaller effect on government hospitals as compared to private hospitals. Mixed effects models estimated negative correlation between cross-time and cross-hospital variations in episiotomy rates, indicating reduced cross-hospital variation over time. Conclusions Our results suggested that there has been a gradual decline in episiotomy rates over the period 2003–2008, and that synthesis of evidence showing harms from routine episiotomy had limited impact on practice patterns in the case of episiotomy. The experience of episiotomy illustrates the challenge of using comparative effectiveness and evidenced-based medicine to reduce use of unnecessary procedures.
The article of record as published may be found at http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00404-013-2904-y
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Evans, Ashley D. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2002-09);A general physics based hydrodynamic flow model is developed that predicts the three-dimensional six degrees of freedom free fall time history of a circular cylinder through the water column to impact with an unspecified ...
Doerr, Kenneth H.; Kang, Keebom (Monterey, California, Naval Postgraduate School, 2014); NPS-LM-12-212This case is intended to illustrate key trade-offs in planning the acquisition of a major weapon system. In particular, the impact of logistics and maintenance decisions on life-cycle costs and readiness are examined. The ...
An analysis of the financial implications of high-impact versus low-impact communications in the United States Navy Colucci, Robert J. (1987-06);This study investigates and analyzes the financial implications associated with the use of high-impact versus low-impact communications in the United States Navy. The study examines the general merit and overall cost ...