Assessment of a novel 3hrs-on/3hrs-off/3hrs- on/15hrs-off watchstanding schedule on the USS STOCKDALE (DDG-106)
Shattuck, Nita Lewis
MetadataShow full item record
This study assessed the utility of the novel 3hrs-on/3hrs-off/3hrs-on/15hrs-off (3-3-3-15) watchstanding schedule on the USS STOCKDALE (DDG 106) while the ship was conducting underway operations. Crewmembers (N=129) completed a survey to provide their opinion about the utility and the acceptance of the 3-3-3-15 as compared to their previous schedule, i.e., the 3hrs-on/9hrs-off (3/9). The novelty of the 3-3-3-15 lies in the clustering of the two shifts, which are divided by a 3-hour off period, and the long 15-hour off period after the second shift. The predicted effectiveness of the 3-3-3-15 was assessed with the Fatigue Avoidance Scheduling Tool (FAST). Crewmembers reported sleeping 5.80±1.23 hours daily. The average PSQI Global score was 7.29±2.89, with ~73% of the participants identified as “poor sleepers”. In comparison to the 3/9, the average rate of non-negative responses of the 3-3-3-15 (to include positive and neutral responses) ranged between 80% and 90%. The largest acceptance (positive) rates were identified in sleep affordability, the adequacy of time to complete off-watch duties and shipboard/departmental qualifications, to work out, to have more personal time, to be able to plan daily activities. Given that sleep satisfaction and acceptance rates of the 3-3-3-15 were equivalent or better than other watchstanding schedules, our results suggest that the 3-3-3-15 may be a useful schedule from an ergonomic and sleep hygiene perspective. Evidence also suggest, however, that the 3-3-3-15 may not be as good for officers whose duties demand high level of situational awareness about ship operations, for watchstanders in the Operations Department or for bridge watch duties. Overall, the 3-3-3-15 has the potential to be a useful alternative to existing watch standing schedules in terms of crew fatigue levels, acceptance by the crewmembers, and workload management when working in a Navy vessel. Being a novel schedule, however, more effort should be focused on how to best implement the 3-3-3-15 on a ship, and what are the factors that affect the utility of the 3-3-3-15 at sea.
Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited.Prepared for: Commanding Officer, USS STOCKDALE (DDG-106)
NPS Report NumberNPS-OR-18-002
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Shattuck, Nita Lewis; Matsangas, Panagiotis; Brown, Stephanie (Monterey, California, Naval Postgraduate School, 2015-04); NPS-OR-15-006This is the second phase of a longitudinal study comparing the fatigue levels, workload, and performance of crewmembers working on the 3-hrs on/9-hrs off (3/9) and the 5-hrs on/10-hrs off (5/10) watchstanding schedules. ...
Assessing the acceptance and functional value of the Asymmetrical Software Kit (ASK) at the tactical level Hopewell, Peter H. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2007-12);The Asymmetrical Software Kit (ASK) is a software package built for U.S Army Special Operations Command (USASOC). It is designed to greatly expand and digitize the Intelligence Preparation of the Battlefield (IPB) process ...
Burgess, Nathan P.; Jordan, Keith A. (Monterey, California: Naval Postgraduate School, 2013-12);This research project is intended to determine if utility modeling could be used within the Department of Defense acquisition community. The primary effort of this research is to create a linear programming-based utility ...