Propagating Uncertainty in Hierarchical Combat Models
Lucas, Thomas W.
Sanchez, Paul J.
MetadataShow full item record
The Office of the Chief of Naval Operations (OPNAV) uses a hierarchy of simulation models as part of scenario-based planning to help decide how the Navy should be equipped, organized, and employed. Simulation is used throughout the acquisition process, from platform design to force structure analysis. In hierarchical combat modeling, the mean outputs of lower-level, higher-resolution models are typically used as inputs to higher-level, lower-resolution models. The objective of this process is to inform Navy leadership on how detailed design changes ultimately impact campaign effectiveness. Unfortunately, by ignoring variability in linkages between layers in the hierarchy, the results may bias campaign-level outcomes or understate the final variability (or risk) estimated by the campaign-level model. The primary goal of this research was to design and run experiments to better understand the impacts on the hierarchical modeling process associated with error propagation methods and design of experiments techniques. Another objective was to developed new algorithms that improve upon our ability to explore high-dimensional combat models. To empirically explore a host of different error propagation approaches, this research conducted thousands of experiments using a two-model hierarchical structure in an air- to-air warfare setting. The results indicate that the manner in which the engagement and campaign models are linked significantly affects the estimates of operational effectiveness and risk. In addition, this research advanced our ability to explore combat models and fit response surfaces through the development and testing of new metamodeling approaches and sequential Latin hypercube methods.
RightsThis publication is a work of the U.S. Government as defined in Title 17, United States Code, Section 101. Copyright protection is not available for this work in the United States.
NPS Report NumberN16-N206-A
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Representing Uncertainty of Hierarchical and Response Surface Models to Improve Design of Experiments Lucas, Thomas W.; Sanchez, Paul J.; McDonald, Mary; Upton, Steve; Pav, Russsell (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2015);The Office of the Chief of Naval Operations (OPNAV) uses a hierarchy of simulation models as part of scenario-based planning to help decide how the Navy should be equipped, organized, and employed. Simulation is used ...
Hypothesis Testing of Edge Organizations: Laboratory Experimentation using the ELICIT Multiplayer Intelligence Game Leweling, Tara A.; Nissen, Mark E. (2007-06);The Edge is a relative newcomer to organizational design--one that appears especially appropriate for contemporary military operations, but also raises issues regarding comparative performance of the Edge to alternate ...
Ilaslan, Salih (Monterey, California: Naval Postgraduate School, 2016-06);Operations research analysts often use a hierarchy of combat models to provide insight to military decision makers. Briefly, lower-level, higher-resolution models provide input to higher-level, lower-resolution models. ...