CIVIL LIBERTIES IN THE ABSENCE OF LEGISLATIVE INTELLIGENCE OVERSIGHT: LESSONS LEARNED FROM URUGUAY
Bihar, Alejandro M.
Mabry, Tristan J.
MetadataShow full item record
This thesis analyzes contemporary civil-military relations in Uruguay with respect to its intelligence organizations. Uruguay operated for twelve years under military dictatorship until 1985, when the country peacefully transitioned to democracy. During the military rule, the Uruguayan intelligence agency, Service of Defense Information, conducted countless human rights violations to include torture, non-judicial killings, and disappearances in support of domestic prerogatives and regional military operations. Despite military constraints, the nation returned to democratic rule. The advancements in rule of law, civil and political society, and flourishing democratic institutions led experts to conclude that Uruguay had achieved consolidation of democracy by 1992. Given the past atrocities of the Uruguayan intelligence agency, this research seeks to understand how a lack of formal legislative intelligence oversight impacts civil liberties and public perception of intelligence in Uruguay. Using a civil-military relations framework for analysis of civilian control, effectiveness, and intelligence culture, this thesis concludes that in the absence of formal mechanisms of democratic institutional oversight and control, informal mechanisms will emerge in the protection of civil liberties.
Approved for public release. distribution is unlimited
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Ulery, Eduardo. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2005-12);This thesis presents an analysis of the past and current political and military situation in Uruguay, and an assessment of the environment in the Southern Cone of Latin America in light of the current leftist regimes in ...
Mitchell, Michael Joseph. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 1988);In recent years South America has witnessed a wave of transitions from military rule. These military regimes were different from past interventions in that the military came to power with their own agenda, not to specifically ...
Insurgents to presidents: contemporary civil-military relations in Brazil, El Salvador, and Uruguay Berg, John Richard (Monterey, California: Naval Postgraduate School, 2016-03);This thesis analyzes contemporary civil–military relations in three Latin American countries: Brazil, El Salvador, and Uruguay. Since 2010, each country has elected a president who was previously an armed insurgent resisting ...