COMPARISON OF REQUIREMENTS UNDERSTANDING IN MODEL-BASED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING VERSUS TRADITIONAL METHODS
Chia, Yong Jie
Giachetti, Ronald E.
Van Bossuyt, Douglas
MetadataShow full item record
Today, Model-Based Systems Engineering (MBSE) is used to meet the fast completion of complex projects and products. Yet, little research has been performed on the cognitive process involved in utilizing models to represent specifications. This thesis studies how well systems engineers can understand requirements in an MBSE environment. Systems engineers using models were tested to determine whether they understand a system in the same way or differently from systems engineers using text-based requirements for the same system. Subjects’ comprehension on model-based versus text-based tactical sling specifications was measured based on the accuracy of the answers provided by the subjects in an online survey. The subjects’ responses were used to evaluate experiment hypotheses and determine the effectiveness, efficiency, usefulness, and usability of modeling languages. Due to the low number of participants, the study could not definitively show whether the systems engineers using models understand system requirements in the same way or differently from systems engineers using text-based versions of the requirements. The study, however, did substantiate that models were more effective for eliciting correct responses to multiple-answer questions, suggesting that systems engineers and stakeholders can comprehend complex system requirements better in an MBSE environment.
Approved for public release. distribution is unlimited
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Mandatory security policy enforcement in commercial off the shelf database management system software : a comparative analysis of Informix-Online/Secure and trusted ORACLE Muschalek, Keith Edward (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 1994-09);The objective of this thesis is to analyze the mandatory access control (MAC) features of two commercial multilevel trusted database management systems (DBMS): Trusted ORACLE 7 and Informix-OnLine/Secure 5.0. We are ...
Tailoring MIL-STD-1472G: developing a system–level MANPRINT requirements document for contract use in the acquisition of military ground combat vehicles Swain, Deborah L. (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2013-09);This document has been created to initiate an artifact which can be further developed into a hard contract requirements document that will mandate human design requirements as critical and requiring accountability on ...
Testing Whether the Adoption of Model-Based Systems Engineering Influences How Stakeholders Think About Systems Giachetti, Ronald; McGuire, Mollie; Holness, Karen (Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School, 2018-04-30); SYM-AM-18-064The Department of Defense is adopting model-based systems engineering in which models will replace the extensive amounts of documentation generated in developing a new system. This research examines how this shift from ...