Assessment of the fixed 3-section 4hrs-on/8hrs-off watchstanding schedule in sailors of the Swedish Royal Navy compared to sailors of the United States Navy
Loading...
Authors
Shattuck, Nita Lewis
Matsangas, Panagiotis
Subjects
Watchstanding schedules
human performance
sleep deprivation
fatigue
sleep quality
psychomotor vigilance performance
human performance
sleep deprivation
fatigue
sleep quality
psychomotor vigilance performance
Advisors
Date of Issue
2021-05
Date
May 2021
Publisher
Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School
Language
Abstract
This prospective longitudinal quasi-experimental study assessed the utility of the 3-section, fixed, 4hrs-on/8hrs-off watchstanding
schedule on a ship of the Swedish Royal Navy (HSwMS ORIOΝ). Sailor (n = 19) state was assessed in terms of sleep attributes,
fatigue, insomnia symptoms, mood, psychomotor vigilance performance, and workload. Data from the HSwMS ORIOΝ were
compared with data from sailors from three surface vessels of the USN (n = 22).
Compared to their USN peers, sailors on the HSwMS ORION were more alert, reported better sleep quality, less severe insomnia
symptoms, and better mood in terms of total mood disturbance, depression, fatigue, and vigor. The same pattern was evident in
psychomotor vigilance performance, i.e., sailors on the HSwMS ORION were faster and made fewer errors as assessed by lapses or
lapses combined with false starts. Sailors in the two samples did not differ in terms of daily sleep duration and the number of sleep
episodes per day. Also, daily work duration did not differ substantively between the two groups. We postulate that one factor that
explains why Swedish sailors felt and performed better is the fact that sailors in night shifts were allowed to wake up later in the day,
and, consequently some work duties occurred later in the day.
In conclusion, our findings suggest the sailor well-being when standing watch on the fixed 4/8 can be improved when sailors are
allowed flexible wake-up times in the morning after a night shift. Given the small number of participants, however, further research is
needed to understand better the advantages and disadvantages of the 4/8 in the naval operational environment, and how to improve the
utility of the watchbill.
Type
Technical Report
Description
Series/Report No
Department
Operations Research (OR)
Organization
Naval Postgraduate School
Identifiers
NPS Report Number
NPS-OR-22-003
Sponsors
Funder
Format
58 p.
Citation
Distribution Statement
Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited.
Rights
This publication is a work of the U.S. Government as defined in Title 17, United States Code, Section 101. Copyright protection is not available for this work in the United States.